Silicone or Saline Implants: It’s Your Choice

Since the FDA approval of silicone gel breast implants, we now have more choices in breast enlargement, breast lift with implant procedures, and breast implant revision.

Why We Use Mentor Breast Implants

Mentor implants in san diego caPlastic surgeons in the U.S. have two main choices of manufacturers for silicone and saline breast implants that are FDA approved. Two companies—Mentor (a Johnson & Johnson company) and Allergan—make excellent products, but we believe Mentor’s breast implants are better. All of our board certified plastic surgeons use Mentor implants almost exclusively. They are also made in the U.S.A.

La Jolla Breast Implants

Despite the fact that we believe Mentor implants are better, you must understand that all saline implants can occasionally leak, wrinkle, or be palpable.

If you prefer saline implants, our board certified plastic surgeons recommend Mentor implants exclusively for the following important reasons:

  • Mentor’s implants have a lower deflation rate, which reduces the need for secondary surgery due to deflation.
  • We prefer the shell (the outer edge) of the Mentor implants because
    • They are less likely to wrinkle and show under your skin when implanted.
    • We’ve found that you are less likely to be able to feel the edges of Mentor implants once they are implanted (i.e, they are less palpable).

Differences Between Silicone and Saline Implants

The following chart outlines the differences between silicone and saline breast implants. Please contact us if you have questions.

Silicone MemoryGel®
Breast Implants

Saline-Filled
Breast Implants

Silicone Gel Breast Implant Saline Breast Implant

√ FDA Approved

√ FDA Approved

Implant Filling

Filled with Silicone Gel. Mentor’s MemoryGel® holds together uniformly while retaining the natural feel of breast tissue.

Implant Filling

Filled with a Saltwater Solution. Like the fluid that makes up most of the human body, saline has a slightly firmer feel than silicone gel.

Fill Volume

Set fill volume, so the surgeon cannot adjust the volume.

Fill Volume

Flexible fill volume, so the surgeon can adjust the volume during the procedure.

Projection Options

Three options: Moderate,
Moderate Plus, High Profile
(see images below)

Projection Options

Three options: Moderate,
Moderate Plus, High Profile

Shell Surfaces

There are two surfaces available: Smooth or textured

Shell Surfaces

There are two surfaces available: Smooth or textured

Incision Size

Slightly larger incision size

Incision Size

Smaller incision size

Warranty

Covered by Mentor’s Standard or Enhanced Advantage Limited Warranty and lifetime replacement policy.

Warranty

Covered by Mentor’s Standard or Enhanced Advantage Limited Warranty and lifetime replacement policy.

Three Profile Choices to Fit Your Body Type

Both saline and silicone gel breast implants come in three profiles: moderate, moderate plus, and high profile. Your plastic surgeon will examine and talk to you at your implant sizing and shaping appointment to recommend the breast implant profile that will best help you achieve your goals.

Moderate

Moderate Plus

High Profile

MemoryGel Moderate Profile MemoryGel Moderate Plus Profile MemoryGel High Profile

Learn More about Breast Implants

Read Dr. Lori Saltz’s series of articles about breast augmentation: